Erroneous Terminal Area Forecasts

 

Hale County airport reporting VFR

Our flight from Aero Country (T31), our home airport near Dallas, to the Hale County airport (KPVW) in Plainview, TX hasn't been very pleasant. There have been low clouds, forcing us into 1,000 ft AGL flight. 

Not to worry. There are no nasty obstacles or troubling magenta areas on our route. All airports along the route are reporting at least marginal VFR, with ceilings predicted to rise, so ceilings cannot come suddenly down and trap us.

The news ahead is even better. Hale County has been reporting VFR for the past hour, with ceilings rapidly rising.

But Hale County is just the first stop of the day. Following the excellent advice of C. Sullenberger, the famous pilot of the miracle landing on the Hudson, we look ahead every 30 minutes and examine the weather-reporting airports right up to the final destination of the day, in this case the Grants-Milan airport (KGNT).

We have been particularly concerned about the Clovis AFB since it was IFR and supplied the following Terminal Area Forecast (TAF) when we departed the Dallas area.

Terminal Area Forecast (TAF) issued 10:00 Zulu

The consistent IFR prediction is worrisome. On other hand, the airport is just 80 nm west of Hale County, and it seems unusual that Hale County has a 6,500 ft ceiling and Clovis is still predicted to be IFR for much of the day. 

Fortunately, as we approach Hale County, the weather at Clovis looks up.

Actual weather at Clovis: Marginal VFR

So here is a weird situation. Actual weather at Clovis has become marginal VFR and no longer is IFR. Indeed, 10 minutes later, Clovis reports VFR with unlimited ceiling. At the same time, the Garmin Pilot still supplies a TAF that predicts IFR for most of the day.

What is Wrong Here?

The situation is just another symptom of the following situation. Technology has moved forward in great strides, but some systems cling to outdated concepts. This includes the supply of weather forecasts for airports by TAFs. 

The forecast should be recomputed hourly and distributed via ADS-B just as happens with the current weather information and radar images.

More Suggestions

When one looks at the current aviation system, one sees a gulf between outdated processes and modern technology. This ranges from the single channel, voice communication only, interaction with ATC and FSS, and the distribution of weather forecasts, to the old-fashioned handling of pilot reports.

For example, there likely would be lots of useful pilot reports if the Garmin Pilot could create a pop-up window where the pilot inserts the relevant information. Upon completion, the information would be broadcast to the FSS, which collates the results and distributes them via ADS-B.

Dreaming?

Sounds like dreaming about a wonderland, doesn't it? But if you had predicted in 1980, when even the FSS didn't have radar images about the current weather, that 40 years later every pilot could have weather radar images on board, you would have been called a hopeless dreamer or worse. 

What is needed isn't criticism of such dreams, but a revolutionary look at how aviation processes should be structured to exploit the advances in technology. The elimination of erroneous TAFs would be one of the many goals. 

Have any questions or feedback about Terminal Area Forecasts? Please share your thoughts in the comments.

 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Testing Rotax 912/914 Generator and Voltage Regulator/Rectifier

Image
Our original installation of the Rotax 912/914 r egulator/ r ectifier. 24 years later, the two brown wires on the left were replaced by yellow wires of a new stator, see photo below. The Rotax 912/914 electrical system may fail unexpectedly. I t happened to us once at a really inconvenient time : S ee Rotax Goes South As We Go West . Most likely the electrical failure is caused by the voltage regulator/rectifier.  To ver ify this , we now carry in the plane a small multimeter that measures AC/DC voltage and resistance and use the checklist below. The checklist assumes a standard installation as described in the Rotax installation manual Section 24-00-00, without additional external generator, and that the voltage is not in the normal range. Testing Electrical System Beyond Regulator/Rectifier It is possible, though quite unlikely, that the electrical failure is caused by something other than the generator and regulator/rectifier. There is an almost infinite variety of poss
Read more

Rotax 912 Engine: 2,400 Hours in 28 Years (achieved in 2023)

Image
Rotax 912 engine The  Rotax 912 engine  in o ur plane, a Zenith 601HDS, has reached an important milestone. Over the past 28 years, it has run 2,400 hrs without major repairs. Zenith 601HDL, N314LB It's appropriate to reflect about this performance and muse how this is possible. After all, when we bought the engine, in 1994, the suggested TBO was 1,200 hrs.  Since then TBO has gone up, first to 1,600 hrs, and more recently to 2,000 hrs. Of course, those increases apply to later engines, not to our early model. Let's see how the engine performs after all this time. Performance after 2,400 hrs Compression is 76-80 lbs/sq.in. on all cylinders. Oil consumption is less than 1/2 qt per 25 hours.  During each oil change, we cut open the filter and look for metal. There is almost none, just one or two tiny specks. Essentially, the engine shows no sign of wear. The engine performs well up to the legal limit of 14,000 ft MSL for flight without oxygen. When flying
Read more

uAvionix TailBeacon: Installation and Testing

Image
TailBeacon of uAvionix mounted on rudder of Zenith 601HDS The uAvionix TailBeacon is a low-cost device that satisfies the ADS-B Out requirement kicking in on January 1, 2020.  The TailBeacon piggybacks on any Mode C or S transponder, and thus avoids purchase of a much more expensive ADS-B transponder.  There are two TailBeacon versions: the TailBeacon TSO for certificated aircraft and the less expensive  TailBeacon  EXP for experimental aircraft.  We bought the EXP version for our Zenith 601HDS, N314LB. uAvionix also offers an alternate ADS-B Out module: the  SkyBeacon .  It uses similar technology, but is installed in a different part of the airplane. Details on this below. T here are two versions: TSO and EXP.   This post covers why we selected the TailBeacon and how we installed, tested, and evaluated it using the  FAA ADS-B Performance Report. It's easy to adapt the process for installation of the SkyBeacon. ADS-B Out Requirement Starting on January 1, 2020,
Read more